In this post, I will talk about what happened in the group discussion. What I find most interesting in the process is how we brought different ideas together, stormed a little bit, and reach consensus in our decision. Also, this is the process where we evolved into a cohesive team and began to perform.
The main topic in this meeting was the specific topic of the presentation and the facilitation strategies we would use. Although we had chosen "power and social influence" as our borad topic, there was no way we would be able to focus on every part of the chapter within half an hour. Melissa proposed to focus on the part of "power dynamic" and relate that part to the films we watch in class. But it seemed that April would like to cover the whole chapter so that we would not limit the discussion. She also volunteered to prepare the handout which would summarize the chapter in two pages and help learners review the content in this chapter. I wish we could touch on every aspect of the chapter to avoid the risk of losing points in evaluation, but I know that deep and inspiring dialogue among learners is also a important criterion of a successful presentation. Therefore, I suggested that we dispatch the handout to learners, and ask them to choose what they want to talk about and teach each other on that topic. Since all the class had read and discussed a little about this chapter, this presentation could be a chance for each learner to bring in their own experience and focus on the learning for themselves. Happily, the team agreed on this idea. Also, we decided to adopt Melissa's idea about the film and she volunteered to lead the presentation in that part.
The beauty of our final design is that each team member's idea counted. No one's idea was excluded. We didn't vote any idea out, but tried to bring them together to a consensus. Therefore, all of us were on board with the final decision and committed to it. During the presentation, each member was leading the part that she originally proposed, which allowed us the freedom to design our own part under the umbrella of the topic. This is very important because it empowered each individuals in the group to realize what we believed was the best for each part. As a member, each of us had the ownership of our contribution as well as the group product. That is the source of achievement and proudness. As Melissa said, working on the ppt of the films was the best thing she did in that week. This is a perfect example of how individual goal and group's goal are synthesized and contribute to support individual development in a group.
Working in such a team is a enjoyment. Every member's talent is accurately allocated so that it serves the team the best. After this meeting, we have moved out from "Storming" into "Performing".
It's very interesting to read this post, and your previous post, and learn how your group went about putting your presentation together. In our group we also had discussions about the balance of focusing on different areas of the chapter while still encouraging in depth discussions from the class. When it comes to Tuckman, the storming part of group development tends to sound like it could be a negative stage. You did a great job in your post of describing the storming stage and explaining how your different opinions ultimately led to this great class presentation. I thought that your team's presentation was great, and I'm sure that had to do with having all of your ideas coming together. Great Job! Lauren
ReplyDeleteI agree with Lauren's assessment. I felt that each of you were very comfortable in presenting the various segments of your facilitation in class. The individual contributions were unique and yet flowed together. If you hadn’t had that ease and comfort within the group, it would have translated in your presentations of the material. I also feel your exercise as a whole reflected your topic: “Power and Social Influence”, along with “Power Dynamics” was displayed in the way you came together as a group. The process that your group underwent along with the time and care you took to share your experience in your blog post, further illustrates how well you each worked together. From what you described there seemed to be a great deal of care used not to negatively influence the individual contributions that your group members were bringing to the project. I really enjoyed your group facilitation also. It really made me think.
ReplyDelete